On April 29, 2007, my girlfriend I and decided to buy some appliances on Sears.com. We found some OK deals, and wanted to ensure we got these before we had to move out of our old apartment in late May. Boy, are we sorry we bought from Sears.com. I’ll list our experiences, chronologically, so we can see how this all got to today:
April 29, 2007: We ordered a washing machine, gas dryer, and refrigerator from Sears.com
May 6, 2007: We receive a phone call from Sears delivery confirming delivery of our appliances the next day
May 7, 2007 (AM): Girlfriend stays home from work in order to receive the appliances. When girlfriend meets delivery guys, they don’t have the fridge. She calls Sears.com and they say the fridge is backordered and will be delivered on May 10. This doesn’t phase Sears.com, even though we are supposed to be out of town on May 10. We pray for early morning delivery of the appliance so as not to delay our trip that much.
May 7, 2007 (PM): Girlfriend is drying a load of laundry and hears loud buzzing sound. When girlfriend attempts to turn down buzzer sound, she realizes that we were given wrong dryer. Appliance matched the picture online, but Sears.com has the wrong part number from the manufacturer tied to the wrong Sears item number and incorrect description. Girlfriend calls to set up exchange that is to take place on Thursday. Awesome, we say. Appliances installed and off on our trip. Not so bad.
May 8, 2007 (AM): Voicemail from Sears asking for a call back about our fridge. Call Sears.com, they say the fridge is backordered until May 15. I’m angry. I ask for two different supervisors, one of which promised a $65 appeasement gift card for the trouble. Upon speaking with the second supervisor and trying to figure out what replacement fridge would be suitable, she informs me that in the time we have been speaking, the availability has been pushed back to May 30. I tell supervisor to cancel this order and give me a refund for the fridge. Supervisor obliges.
May 8, 2007 (Late AM): Go to a Sears retail store and buy floor model fridge. Experience is great. When asking retail person about our fridge model she says “Oh, that model has been backordered for a long time.” Awesome to know, considering that Sears.com said the model was in stock and ready for delivery.
May 8, 2007 (PM): I talk with Sears.com folks about our dryer exchange to ENSURE that the correct dryer is being delivered on Thursday, and I am told that yes, the correct dryer will be delivered.
May 9, 2007 (PM): Girlfriend stays home from work again to receive fridge. Fridge is delivered late in the day, but working great. Yay for Sears retail. Sears.com calls girlfriend to say our dryer will be delivered tomorrow morning. Sears.com calls me to say our dryer will be delivered tomorrow morning. How nice of them to call both of us about the situation, we say.
May 10, 2007 (AM): Girlfriend and I are at home when delivery guys come. The same WRONG dryer is at our door. When we tell the delivery guy that the dryer for girlfriend is wrong, he says that he has another of the SAME model dryer in the truck for me. I tell him that that dryer is wrong too. Speaking on the phone with Sears.com, they say that the dryer will be exchanged for the PROPER unit on May 18, when the girlfriend and I are back in town and I am off of work. Riiiiight, we say.
May 11, 2007 (AM): I get a voicemail asking us to call back about our exchange. We are on vacation, and I am unable to call back that day.
May 12, 2007 (AM): Girlfriend gets a phone call from Sears saying they are trying to exchange our dryer and nobody is answering the door. We tell them that the exchange was supposed to take place on May 18 and that we are out of town. They have no real response.
May 14, 2007: Girlfriend talks on the phone with agent who is willing to get it all sorted out and get us the right dryer, since all of these problems are stemming from incorrect information on their website. Girlfriend sets up exchange for May 18.
May 15, 2007 (AM): Today is my birthday. I decided that I wasn’t going to leave our dryer up to chance again, and I don’t want any more shit in my Cheerios on my birthday. I stop by another Sears retail store (different from the fridge location) and speak with a salesperson about the situation. She speaks with her manager, and her manager immediately approves price matching the wrong online price and sets up delivery for May 18. Wonderful experience.
May 15, 2007 (Late AM): Spoke with Sears.com, told them I wanted to cancel the exchange and have them pick up the old dryer for a refund of the dryer and the service contract. Agent stated that would be OK and ended the call.
May 16, 2007: Girlfriend gets a call from Sears saying that they are at our apartment trying to pick up the old dryer and deliver the correct dryer. Girlfriend tells them that this is supposed to be a pickup only and on May 18. Delivery guys say OK. I speak with Sears.com later and CONFIRM that Friday is pickup for refund ONLY.
May 17, 2007 (PM): Confirmed with Sears that pickup of old dryer and delivery of new dryer are both scheduled for late afternoon on May 18. Yay!
May 18, 2007 (AM): I’m at my grandma’s house telling them the story so far about our Sears.com experience and I get a phone call from girlfriend. Girlfriend says that Sears called saying that the product we had for exchange was damaged and that exchange would have to take place May 19. Girlfriend says that no exchange is set and this should be pickup only. They say OK.
May 18, 2007 (PM): Sears delivers the correct dryer purchased from retail 30 minutes before their scheduled window. Awesome! I asked the guys if they were picking up the old dryer for refund and they say no. Alright, I say. I gave the guys each a Coke (they looked really thirsty) and said thanks for moving the incorrect dryer to the patio for temporary storage. I then call Sears delivery to CONFIRM that they are in fact picking up the wrong dryer today. Sears says that they cannot pick up the old one since it was part of an exchange. They cancelled the exchange and now say that the soonest they can pick up the wrong dryer is May 20. I say fine, but this is ridiculous and they suggest I contact Sears.com. I called Sears.com where the agent said there is nothing I could do about it. I asked for a supervisor and, instead of connecting me with a supervisor, he said that his supervisor said there was nothing they could do. I hang up, register SearsRuinedMyLife.com and started to document this experience online.
So far, it appears that Sears Retail is 2 for 2 and Sears.com is 1 for 3. If you count EACH of the times they delivered the wrong item to us, Sears.com is even worse. I’m at a loss as to what I should do. I don’t have my token $65 gift card, my girlfriend is out two days of work because of Sears.com, and I’ve got a dryer I don’t want taking up space on my patio on the 3rd floor of my apartment building. This has been the worst customer service experience I’ve ever had to deal with, and God knows I’m never ordering anything from Sears.com ever again. If it weren’t for the reassurance of a friend of mine who is a manager at a Sears retail store and the extremely positive experience I had with the retail division of Sears, I would have given up on Sears long ago.
It seems like this behemoth of a company has a pretty decent supply and service chain with its retail business but obviously has no clue when it comes to running an internet business. I work for a major retailer, and I can tell you that if this were a customer of ours, he’d have probably been given new equipment at little to no cost AND given a full refund. This is unacceptable for any company to tolerate, but it seems that Sears.com not only tolerates it, they feel little need to change the status quo.
Any similar experiences? Suggestions? Questions? Please email me, or better yet, post your responses on the site. I’ll do my best to oblige.
Thanks for reading.